An Expert Look at Navigating Then & Now
Date Posted: June 26, 2023
Source: Bob Sherer (aka Bob423), Contributor

Being on the water has always been adventurous. And for all the reasons that we love boating the one task that has evolved more than any other in the past 25 years is navigation.

GPS coverage and accuracy combined with the processing power of today's mobile devices and chart plotters provide a level of precision and confidence heretofore unavailable.

Contributing editor Bob Sherer (aka Bob423) compiled a list of activities that we exercised when we plotted courses and skippered our boats at the turn of the 21st century and compared them to how we get around today. Do you remember when?

Then

  • You had a library of paper charts stowed on the boat.
  • Your routes and waypoints were plotted on those charts.
  • Parallel rulers were used with the chart's compass rose.
  • You had a back-sighting compass in addition to an on the helm compass.
  • You knew how to dead reckon because you never knew when fog would close in, or you could not determine your location from celestial observations.
  • There was a stopwatch on board, and you probably had a good wristwatch.
  • You could identify bell buoys (ATONs) and estimate direction and distance to and from them.
  • You were aware of other sounds such as water lapping against shore or the sound of other boats, especially in fog or reduced visibility.
  • You learned how to estimate distances to ATONs by their apparent size.
  • You understood foghorn signals.

Advancements along the way

  • We transferred waypoints from paper charts to our GPS devices to make routes.
  • Then chart plotters arrived and what a revolution. You could see your boat icon moving on the chart on the screen. Wow!
  • Charts gradually were not spread out or referenced while underway.

 

Now

The proliferation of Apple and Android navigation apps with capabilities far beyond those early chart plotters.

  • Chart plotter functions are now available in many mobile navigation apps.
  • There is a standard format (.GPX) for sharing waypoints, routes, and tracks.
  • We get multiple chart updates per year (versus the one or two updates we got with old style chart plotters.
  • Weather information is integrated into many mobile navigation apps.
  • Tides and currents are now superimposed on digital devices, which assist in estimating time to destinations and drift.
  • Digital data from NOAA and USACE is now available to recreational boaters and mobile apps are amazingly robust, such as Aqua Map that displays USACE, ATON relocations and LNMs. SonarChart from Navionics maps bottom contours of the waterways.
  • Community comments and reviews of anchorages, marinas and local conditions are available with a finger tap on many apps.
  • AIS is inexpensive and accurate for most any vessel owner that wants to install it offering greatly improved visibility for all vessels.

 

Reflection

Are we safer now than in the past with these new technologies?

  • What if they fail and we have no GPS, a mobile device dies, or a software update kills an app?
  • Multiple backups are needed for devices and software, which complicates the equation.
  • Do we still need to learn the navigation skills of yesteryear? Very few of us are going back to a sextant for coastal cruising. But basic navigation skills and situational awareness are still required. Know the ATONs (red, right, returning), port to port on-coming passing, and give way versus stand on vessel positions.

 

Boating should be fun and part of having fun is being safe. Modern tools provide accurate tracks, timely weather information, including weather radar via internet, electronic navigation charts (ENC) with regular data updates, USACE surveys displayed for navigation and so much more.

 

There is little nostalgia for the old tools of navigation. They worked in their time, but today's technologies are better and we're not going backwards. Where will we be in another 25 years?

Comment Submitted by Ed Wise - July 1, 2023
I've learned by experience that not keeping a paper plot in addition to all electronics information is asking for trouble. Besides, I think navigating the old way is fun!
Comment Submitted by Gary Haring - June 29, 2023
When it comes to boating the active word is "safety". Skippers should always practice safe boating which include knowing where your vessel is at all times in any circumstance. This is by far easier today than in the "good old days" where my nostalgic remembrances are not fond. I never really knew exactly where I was most of the time back then. I had a rough idea and when pressed I would boldly point to the chart and say "we are here" when in fact it was a calculated guess. However, a guess is better than not knowing and I vividly remember a long, long time ago, when I temporarily did not know my vessel's position. Not a pleasant feeling and embarrassing when I felt compelled to ask the captain to stop the vessel while I figured it out. I lost some credibility with the crew that day BUT was forgiven after I bought the rounds that night. While I no longer make my living navigating I embraced the accuracy of electronic equipment when I was. My first loran set eliminated the need for inducing an error in the course line, I could aim straight for an inlet but even today I still offset some. My first GPS was a game changer with its lollypop tied to the radar unit. With a glance I instantly knew if the helmsman was holding the course true. My first chart plotter with integrated and overlaid radar sealed the deal for it was the first time I knew exactly the relative position of that fog horn. AIS. What can I say. I can almost read the mind of that captain bearing down on me. What's not to like about modern navigation equipment? I'll tell you and it is scary. While modern equipment is great and has certainly reduced the number of accidents it can also give a false sense of security. This coupled with the slow degradation in skills of the average skipper all adds up to being one little mistake away from disaster. I'll give you a comparison. Following a GPS course crossing the Gulf Steam for the Bahamas on the day Desert Storm started suddenly the GPS went haywire. However, I had marked our last position on the PAPER chart 15 minutes ago and it was no worries calculating a course line to nail the Bimini harbor inlet. Compared this incident to 90 miles off the coast of Jacksonville an open runabout came up to us and ask which way to the St. Johns River. Seems their cell phone app quit working and they had been wandering around lost ! I gave them a compass with west marked on it and told them when they get about a mile off shore turn right and keep going until they run into the river. I don't know if they made it, I never got my compass back. The point is learning practical navigation skills doesn't have to be fun because it is necessary for safety purposes. Everyone, even those who never venture past the jetties should take a navigation course because mistakes made on the water are unforgiving. And how impressive is it to never have to ask for directions.
Explore More News & Articles In Specific Cruising Areas
Recent Videos
Plan Your Boating Adventures with Waterway Guide
Waterway Guide's new Mobile App on iPad Mini with maps, data links, and downloadable guide books
Fuel Prices for Boating at Waterwayguide.com
Purchase a Guide
  • 4,000 Marinas
  • Thousands of anchorages
  • Updated Charts
  • Mile-by-Mile Navigation
  • Highlighted Alerts & Cautions
  • Full-Color Aerial Photographs
Download The App

The Waterway Guide App Makes it easy to leave reviews, use our explorer, and view waterway guide materials all on the go!