Reviews: Rudder Cay Beach

These are observations from the boating community. Waterway Guide information is verified regularly and all efforts will be made to validate any new updates submitted here. Thank you for taking the time to share comments about your experience.

Waterway Guide reserves the option of editing reviews and comments for grammar, clarity and the removal of defamatory or potentially slanderous language. When appropriate, reviews are forwarded to businesses for response prior to being made public. We will make every effort to be objective and impartial when posting reviews, but do not publicize details of disputes between parties.

Thanks for your valuable feedback!
Holding:
3.67
Good holding in sand
Wind Protection:
4.00
N-SE
Current Flow:
3.33
Wake Protection:
3.67
Scenic Beauty:
4.67
Ease of Shopping:
1.00
Shore Access:
3.33
Private Beach nearby
Pet Friendly:
3.67
Private beach nearby
Cell Service:
2.67
Fair Coverage
WiFi:
1.00

  • Review for Rudder Cay Beach

    Reviewed by: Jason Spitz, Breathe, on Mar 12, 2024
    Vessel Type: Sail
    LOA: 40'
    Draft: 4.0'

    Overall Rating:
    4
    Holding:
    4
    Wind Protection:
    4
    Current Flow:
    2
    Wake Protection:
    3
    Scenic Beauty:
    4
    Ease of Shopping:
    1
    Shore Access:
    3
    Pet Friendly:
    4
    Cell Service:
    2

    We returned to Rudder Cut Cay just shy of 1 year from our last visit. We came in to 22 boats, the most we've seen by far. We had a turning of winds with some westerly. Between the lack of protection west and the current that flows more North to South, most of the boats in the anchorage were beam to the wind. Uncomfortable to say the least. 23 boats became 7 boats in the morning, but was back to over a dozen by nightfall. As the winds turned N-NE-E, the anchorage becomes more pleasant. Note that multiple tour boats come through to swim with the turtles, see the cave, the Piano Player and David Copperfield's Musha Cay. So be prepared for a few wakes from speedboats with tourists. We shot some video of the snorkel spots. You can view the video here https://fb.watch/qMpYmOMpet/?

    View location on the Waterway Guide Explorer


  • Review for Rudder Cay Beach

    Reviewed by: Jason Spitz, Breathe, on Mar 25, 2023
    Vessel Type: Sail
    LOA: 40'
    Draft: 4.0'

    Overall Rating:
    4
    Holding:
    4
    Wind Protection:
    4
    Current Flow:
    4
    Wake Protection:
    4
    Scenic Beauty:
    5
    Ease of Shopping:
    1
    Shore Access:
    4
    Pet Friendly:
    4
    Cell Service:
    3
    WiFi:
    1

    Rudder cut is beginning to become a popular anchorage And was quite busy this year with boats spilling well into the deeper recommended cut. Boats transiting the cut should be aware of anchored boats in the "channel". The cove itself quickly shallows to less than 4ft MLW, so boats should use caution.

    There is very good protection from N to ESE winds. As winds turn SE/SSE, there is some side swell that may present itself. The cay itself is private, but there is a nice beach in the eastern corner.

    There is good snorkeling at the cave in the SE corner and David Copperfields Piano and the Mermaid Statue is close by.

    Here's some photos from the cave/reef in the anchorage:
    https://www.facebook.com/100063618668322/posts/pfbid02e2VetgT5bMyysizZpcZCXKCbCiR5n7eVFCAhLFwEg64gk7mdgYdKkgechoXB9XTl/

    View location on the Waterway Guide Explorer


  • Review for Rudder Cay Beach

    Reviewed by: Alex Tarlecky on Mar 20, 2022
    Vessel Type: Sail
    LOA: 42'
    Draft: 4.0'

    Overall Rating:
    4
    Holding:
    3
    Wind Protection:
    4
    Current Flow:
    4
    Wake Protection:
    4
    Scenic Beauty:
    5
    Ease of Shopping:
    1
    Shore Access:
    3
    Pet Friendly:
    3
    Cell Service:
    3
    WiFi:
    1

    Used navionics sonar charts to navigate in through the north entrance and when leaving out through the south channel. Very shallow but instead of entering on the high tide, try entering on the mid to lowering tide because the tide swing here is probably 4 feet or so and you do not want to mistakenly anchor in a shallow spot - you will end up on the sand. We anchored slightly east of the waterway guide mark and at low tide had maybe 6" under the keel. We had a calm night but when the current is running out in the channel it sends little swell-lets into the anchorage... maybe 6 inches or so. Not enough to cause us to bump bottom but noticeable. There appears to be a fairly thin layer of sand over hard pan so while the mantus got some bite I wouldn't call it "sunk in". Snorkeling was good with Rays, Turtles, Fish, some coral. Although the island is privately held we saw no one around (no dogs as far as I could tell) and lots of people were using the beaches. Easy access to the Piano statue. There are a few paths around the island that a long long time ago were paved. Nice palm trees in a small section, unkempt. We had an almost full moon that only added to the charm. However, IMO, no boat with a draft of over 4 feet should attempt to anchor here. Internet was iffy...

    View location on the Waterway Guide Explorer

View in Waterway Explorer