Reviews: Cuttyhunk Pond

These are observations from the boating community. Waterway Guide information is verified regularly and all efforts will be made to validate any new updates submitted here. Thank you for taking the time to share comments about your experience.

Waterway Guide reserves the option of editing reviews and comments for grammar, clarity and the removal of defamatory or potentially slanderous language. When appropriate, reviews are forwarded to businesses for response prior to being made public. We will make every effort to be objective and impartial when posting reviews, but do not publicize details of disputes between parties.

Thanks for your valuable feedback!

Holding:
5.00
Fair, Grass, Sand
Wind Protection:
4.67
All around
Current Flow:
5.00
Wake Protection:
5.00
All around
Scenic Beauty:
5.00
Ease of Shopping:
1.75
Shore Access:
5.00
Pet Friendly:
5.00
Cell Service:
4.00
WiFi:
1.50

  • Review for Cuttyhunk Pond

    Reviewed by: Martin Blanchard, S/V No Brainer, on Jul 8, 2024
    Vessel Type: Sail
    LOA: 42'
    Draft: 4.0'

    Overall Rating:
    5
    Holding:
    5
    Wind Protection:
    5
    Current Flow:
    5
    Wake Protection:
    5
    Scenic Beauty:
    5
    Ease of Shopping:
    3
    Shore Access:
    5
    Pet Friendly:
    5
    Cell Service:
    3

    This is a lovely small island! We got in with heavy fog so that was stressful but once inside the pond, it's super sheltered and calm. We used our electric scooters to go through all the roads on the island. Lots of fun. The views on top of the hill, where the WWII bunker is, are spectacular.
    The raw bar crew comes to your boat every night and offers clam chowder , fresh Cuttyhunk oysters, clams and shrimps. It's a bit pricey but it is definitely worth it. These kids are awesome! Great summer job.
    Will definitely come back . This will have to be a yearly thing now ;)

    • WG Editor Comment:

      Photos courtesy Martin Blanchard, S/V No Brainer

    View location on the Waterway Guide Explorer


  • Review for Cuttyhunk Pond

    Reviewed by: Joseph Apicella, Glory Days, on Jul 9, 2023
    Vessel Type: Sail
    LOA: 50'
    Draft: 3.0'

    Overall Rating:
    5
    Holding:
    5
    Wind Protection:
    5
    Current Flow:
    5
    Wake Protection:
    5
    Scenic Beauty:
    5
    Ease of Shopping:
    1
    Shore Access:
    5
    Cell Service:
    5
    WiFi:
    1

    Cuttyhunk is a great stop. We have been coming here for 40 years. The mooring pendants are about 4' above the ball making it easier to get a line through. The raw bar boat sell oyster, shrimp, and chowder, pricey, but good. The Harbormaster will pick up the $55 early evening. Be sure to have breakfast at the bass club. Hike up to the WW 2 bunker for fantastic views.

    View location on the Waterway Guide Explorer


  • Review for Cuttyhunk Pond

    Reviewed by: Ric Sanders on Aug 19, 2022
    Vessel Type: Sail
    LOA: 42'
    Draft: 0.0'

    Overall Rating:
    5
    Holding:
    5
    Wind Protection:
    3
    Current Flow:
    5
    Wake Protection:
    5
    Scenic Beauty:
    5
    Shore Access:
    5
    Cell Service:
    4

    Had a great stop here. Harbormaster led us to where he wanted us to anchor which was a great experience. Anchor set well on 5 to 1 scope in 20 knots of wind and we did not move until we picked it upSo nice we stayed an extra day. Got chowder and oysters from the kids on the raw bar boat which while was a bit expensive was worth it, at least to us.

    View location on the Waterway Guide Explorer


  • Review for Cuttyhunk Pond

    Reviewed by: Karen Bensley, Clare, on Jun 8, 2019
    Vessel Type: Power
    LOA: 36'
    Draft: 4.5'

    Overall Rating:
    5
    Wind Protection:
    5
    Scenic Beauty:
    5
    Ease of Shopping:
    1
    Shore Access:
    5

    Here early in the season so quiet and uncrowded. Picked up a town mooring (labeled “town rental”) but noted there is some room for anchoring on the northeast corner of the mooring field.

    Friendly and knowledgeable harbormaster who is also police/fireman/animal control. Cooking lobster and lobster dinners on the dock as well as a raw bar boat that circles the mooring field.

    Great walking throughout the island, beautiful views of Martha’s Vineyard as well as the roses and beach peas along the beaches.

    Hadn’t been here in years but worth the early season stop on our way from Maine to NY.

    View location on the Waterway Guide Explorer


  • Review for Cuttyhunk Pond

    Reviewed by: Tom Hale on Aug 26, 2018
    Vessel Type: Power
    LOA: 38'
    Draft: 4.5'

    Overall Rating:
    5
    Holding:
    5
    Wind Protection:
    5
    Current Flow:
    5
    Wake Protection:
    5
    Scenic Beauty:
    5
    Ease of Shopping:
    2
    Shore Access:
    5
    Pet Friendly:
    5
    Cell Service:
    3
    WiFi:
    2

    The inner harbor has mooring available to rent for $45/night. There is very limited room to anchor in the pond. Big town dinghy dock for access to restaurants. You can order steamed lobster and other seafood and pick them up at 5:00

    View location on the Waterway Guide Explorer


  • Review for Cuttyhunk Pond

    Reviewed by: Jim Nichols, MARNICK, on Aug 11, 2016
    Vessel Type: Power
    LOA: 44'
    Draft: 4.6'

    Overall Rating:
    5
    Holding:
    5
    Wind Protection:
    5
    Current Flow:
    5
    Wake Protection:
    5
    Scenic Beauty:
    5
    Shore Access:
    5
    Pet Friendly:
    5
    Cell Service:
    5

    Best known spot for layover to/from Block Island/Martha's Vineyard or Nantucket.

    View location on the Waterway Guide Explorer

View in Waterway Explorer